Two closures and two different story lines. One makes huge headlines, while the other barely gets a margin story amongst all of the business highlights. One details and chronicles all of the wrongdoings and alleged wrongdoings. The other barely mentions problems and in passing indicates the bank will re-open under new ownership and a new name. Both are in the State of Florida. One has a companion story about a renegade mortgage lender which really was a resurrection of a story from some time ago. The other, well, you get the idea. I guess the question is "why?" Why does the story of First State Bank get hardly any airplay? Of course, Taylor Bean is a national story, but here in Florida, this is big news with respect to the bank. [To be fair, troubled Colonial Bank has gotten a lot of coverage].
One of the noticeable banks along the stretch of 4th Street North in St Petersburg, First State will have a new name on Monday and it will open with a new sign in place and the depositors largely will have been clueless about the local Sarasota-based bank even having had issues. Taylor Bean's closure affects thousands of people. Those who closed loans and did not receive funding chief among them. Also the thousands of employees and clients of their wholesale operation--many of whom are small community banks--and potential clients whose access to some programs is now in jeopardy.
I am not going to go into all of the details surrounding the reasons that led to the failure of Taylor Bean as it has been well-chronicled elsewhere. And I am unable to go into the details surrounding the failure of the bank because it has NOT been well-chronicled elsewhere. It does add fuel to the fire, however, in the raging battle against the mortgage broker in the public eye. There have been some problem mortgage brokers in the whole mess we find ourselves in and many of them have moved on into such fields as loan modification, credit repair and foreclosure rescue. Which leaves the industry with mostly honest hardworking brokers who have their clients' best interests at heart while finding the best mortgage product available.
It is curious, however, that many of the other participants in the mortgage meltdown have largely escaped the media & legislative onslaught that rages against mortgage brokers. There are common threads in failed loans. And the tools are there to find them. Appraisers, Realtors, Lenders, Banks, Builders, Consumers, Loan Officers [retail, wholesale AND broker], Securitizers [secondary market folks like Fannie, Freddie, the late Bear Stearns etc] and others all played a role. Underwriters, too, played a role as they are the people who actually approve the loans. But, it is less glamorous to go after the bad guys than it is to make a public statement or policy that will ultimately harm the consumer. Some good things such as Loan Officer registries have come out of all of this, but there is a lot more bad. And that will take some time to bear out.
Recent Comments